Subscribe
advertisement
Food & Drink

Deerslayer Whiskey Tastes Like Deer Camp in a Bottle

Deer camp in a glass? Deerslayer whiskey blends smoked venison, rye and woodsy botanicals into a savory 99-proof pour that tastes far more deliberate—and drinkable—than the premise suggests.

Deerslayer Whiskey Tastes Like Deer Camp in a Bottle

Deer camp has a flavor that unlocks memories: a heavy dose of smoke, a good amount of whiskey and notes of venison drifting through the air. It’s not a combination you can duplicate anywhere else. When it hits your senses, it brings you back to cherished times with some of your favorite people.

But what if you could bottle all of that—and make it strong enough to deliver a buzz?

A small New Hampshire distillery has done exactly that. Tamworth Distilling’s Deerslayer whiskey is made with rye, smoked red deer and forest-inspired botanicals. At 99 proof, it is a venison-flavored whiskey designed to evoke autumn in New England and, intentionally or not, deer camp.

“We’ve always prided ourselves on making things that are unique, that you can’t find anywhere else, using ingredients that you won’t find other people using,” said Matt Power, Tamworth Distilling’s head distiller and biochemist.

Tamworth Distilling founder Steven Grasse stands outside the distillery beside a branded delivery truck.
Steven Grasse, founder and owner of Tamworth Distilling, outside the distillery in Tamworth, New Hampshire.

“We wanted something with smoke in it, and we joked that we don’t have much peat here in New Hampshire, but we do have a lot of smoked meat. Hunting is really big here, so we just kinda took that idea and ran with it.”

What Is Deerslayer Whiskey?

Deerslayer whiskey begins with locally sourced red deer, but Tamworth does more than drop a hunk of meat into a barrel of rye.

The distillery hand-chops the venison and combines it with cranberries, porcini mushrooms, juniper berries and green peppercorns. Those ingredients reinforce the whiskey’s distinctly woodsy character: pine from the juniper, earthiness from the mushrooms, spice from the peppercorns and a little fruit from the cranberries.

The mixture ferments overnight to accentuate the venison’s gaminess. It is then slow-smoked over seasoned wood from New Hampshire’s boreal forests.

Bottle of Deerslayer venison-flavored whiskey with cuts of venison smoking on a grill behind it.
A bottle of 99-proof Deerslayer Venison Flavored Whiskey alongside the smoked meat that gives the spirit its savory character.

“The juniper, porcini, green peppercorn and cranberry are used in small amounts to build this woodsy, autumnal character around the venison,” Power said. “Fermenting and smoking the venison brings out those savory aromas, while the rye gives us a spicy backbone that can stand up to them.”

advertisement

The goal, he added, is for Deerslayer “to taste like the New England woods in the fall—not just like a piece of venison in a glass.”

First released as an experimental spirit in 2020, Deerslayer developed enough of a following to earn a permanent place in Tamworth’s core lineup. In September 2026, the distillery introduced a new 500ml “Buck-sized” bottle alongside the original 200ml “Bambi” bottle.

How Do You Make Venison Whiskey?

Creating a venison-flavored whiskey isn’t as simple as throwing deer meat into a cask. Power and his crew get much more granular—literally.

After the venison mixture has fermented and smoked, the team breaks it down and combines it with whiskey. Power memorably described the result as a sort of “whiskey-sausage chum.”

“We’re able to distill that crude chum into a clear, aromatic whiskey that has a lot of the characteristics of the eating experience,” he said.

Copper pot stills and stainless-steel distillation columns inside Tamworth Distilling.
Copper and stainless-steel distilling equipment inside Tamworth Distilling’s production facility in New Hampshire.

The smoked venison mixture undergoes its final distillation in a rotary evaporator, capturing its aroma and flavor without leaving meat floating in the finished bottle. That concentrated spirit tastes more like smoked meat than rye on its own, so the distillers blend it with aged rye whiskey.

advertisement
advertisement

“We call it three-times-distilled whiskey that has the characteristics of the sausage,” Power said. “It’s 99 proof—or just one short of a buck.”

Meat-Flavored Spirits Aren’t Entirely New

The idea of introducing meat to alcohol has a long, strange history.

Cock ale, an English drink documented centuries ago, incorporated cooked rooster into a strong ale. Mezcal de pechuga is traditionally redistilled with fruit, spices and a chicken or turkey breast suspended inside the still. More recently, bartenders have used bacon-fat-washed bourbon, bone broth and other savory ingredients in cocktails.

Deerslayer applies that same broad idea to venison, rye whiskey and the flavors of a New Hampshire forest. The result sounds like novelty liquor, but it doesn’t taste like something created merely to win a bet.

New Hampshire mountain framed by orange and yellow autumn foliage beneath low clouds.
Tamworth Distilling designed Deerslayer to taste “like the New England woods in the fall,” combining venison with smoky, earthy and fruit-forward flavors.

What Does Deerslayer Whiskey Taste Like?

The first thing you notice is smoke.

advertisement

Deerslayer whiskey has an aroma that initially recalls Scotch. Instead of the earthy, medicinal peat found in many smoky Scotches, however, Deerslayer delivers the smell of a wood fire with something savory cooking nearby.

The venison presents itself as a soft layer of umami rather than an aggressive meat flavor. It rounds out some of the whiskey’s heat and gives the rye a richer, fuller character. Juniper and porcini reinforce that forest-floor quality, while berry notes begin to appear after the first few sips.

An Expert's View
Matt Meltzer
Contributing Writer

Deerslayer whiskey has an aroma that initially recalls Scotch. Instead of the earthy, medicinal peat found in many smoky Scotches, however, Deerslayer delivers the smell of a wood fire with something savory cooking nearby.

The whiskey is complex enough that it benefits from slow drinking. Each sip reveals another part of the recipe: smoke first, then rye spice, savory venison and, finally, cranberry and other dark-fruit notes.

advertisement

Does it taste like liquid deer steak? No. It tastes like whiskey—just whiskey with a smoky, savory flavor that brings deer camp to mind.

advertisement

That distinction has helped Deerslayer outgrow its initial reputation as a curiosity.

“We’ve seen a great interest from hunters,” Power said. “They’ll grab a bottle, bring it up to camp, show their friends, and they say, ‘Hey, this isn’t bad! It tastes like whiskey!’”

ottle of Deerslayer venison whiskey beside a deer antler and James Fenimore Cooper’s novel The Deerslayer on a moss-covered log.
Tamworth Distilling’s Deerslayer whiskey meets its literary namesake, James Fenimore Cooper’s 1841 novel The Deerslayer. Photo by Jenn Bakos.

What’s the Best Way to Drink Deerslayer?

Drink it neat, at least for the first pour.

Water and ice don’t open Deerslayer up the way they can with a more traditional high-proof whiskey. The venison and botanicals are already the stars of the show, and dilution tends to mute the flavors that make the whiskey interesting.

A room-temperature pour provides the clearest progression from smoke to umami, rye spice and fruit. If 99 proof is more heat than you enjoy, add only a few drops of water before committing an entire pour to ice.

advertisement

Deerslayer could also make an intriguing Old Fashioned, particularly with bitters that complement its smoke and spice. Still, the first taste should be unadorned. You bought venison whiskey. You might as well find out what it tastes like.

Is Deerslayer More Than a Novelty?

The original 200ml bottle made sense for an experimental spirit. It was small enough for curious drinkers who weren’t ready to commit to a full-size bottle of meat-flavored whiskey.

The introduction of a 500ml bottle—and Deerslayer’s move into Tamworth’s core spirits lineup—signals that people are returning for more than the story printed on the label.

“It’s transcended the novelty and kind of become something that we could see people wanna have on their bars,” Power said. “Both as a talking point, but also as a product that is real.”

advertisement

The whiskey will always be a conversation starter. Its staying power, however, comes from the fact that there is a coherent flavor behind the gimmick. Smoke, rye, venison, mushrooms, juniper, pepper and cranberry all point in the same direction: toward the woods in fall.

Tamworth Distilling founder Steven Grasse sits beside rows of wooden whiskey barrels.
Founder Steven Grasse inside Tamworth Distilling. Visitors can sample the distillery’s unconventional spirits and purchase Deerslayer at its Tamworth, New Hampshire, tasting room, subject to availability.

Where Can You Buy Deerslayer Whiskey?

Tamworth lists the 500ml bottle at $45, subject to availability. The original 200ml bottle also remains in the lineup. The distillery advertises direct shipping to eligible customers in 45 states, although buyers should confirm current inventory and shipping restrictions through the Tamworth Distilling online store.

Deerslayer is also distributed through New Hampshire Liquor & Wine Outlets, select Massachusetts retailers and the Tamworth Distilling tasting room at 15 Cleveland Hill Road in Tamworth, New Hampshire.

A visit to the tasting room offers the chance to sample Deerslayer alongside some of Tamworth’s other unconventional spirits, including a whiskey flavored with beaver castoreum.

Take a flight outside, sit beneath the trees and watch the foliage or snowfall.

It might not be deer camp, but at least it will taste like it.

If you enjoyed this article, be sure to check out more Whiskey coverage from Hook & Barrel:

advertisement
Something Exclusive

NOTIFY ME